| Platinum | Midnight Taco |
| Gold | XJ's Casa Reynoso |
| Silver | Rancho De Tia Rosa |
| Bronze | Rio Rico Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Barrio Queen |
| Top Pick | Isabel's Amor |
| Top Pick | LA Ristra New Mexican Kitchen |
| Top Pick | New Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Someburros |
| Top Pick | Tacos Califa |